Plant-Based vs Vegan Diets: Which Is Better For You?

A rainbow spread of fresh fruits, vegetables, mushrooms and nuts on a dark table
Photo by Jan Landau on Unsplash
Plant-based and vegan diets aren't the same thing. What each one cuts, what the big studies found, and the nutrients both need to watch.

Unless you live inside a McDonald’s, I’m pretty sure you’ve heard about vegan and plant-based diets. You may have seen new vegan meat substitutes (plant-based burgers, tofurky and the like) or frozen meals labeled as plant-based showing up in your local grocery store. You’re probably also seeing the word “vegan” on a lot of products as well.

But do you know what each diet entails? What are the differences when it comes to plant-based vs vegan diets? Are they the same diet or something different? And if they’re different, which diet may be more beneficial to you, your lifestyle, and your health? Let’s find out.

A wooden bowl of rice, chickpeas, greens and potatoes
Photo by JAEGON LEE on Unsplash

Plant-Based vs Vegan Diets: What Is A Plant-Based Diet?

A plant-based diet is often used as a synonym for a vegan diet when in reality, it is different. For example, on a vegan diet, all animal products are excluded. A plant-based diet can include minimal animal products, but most of the diet should come from plants. 

Think of it this way, plant-based can mean a lot of things, while vegan is one very specific diet. A plant-based diet is a diet category encompassing multiple diets like lacto-ovo vegetarian, pescetarian, and strict vegetarian/vegan diet. When someone says they are plant-based, it is best to clarify what they mean when they say this.

Plant-Based vs Vegan at a Glance

Vegetarian diets exclude some, but not all, animal products. Depending on the kind of vegetarian diet, some people may still eat dairy products and eggs and some vegetarians may even eat fish. Vegan diets exclude all animal products.

Plant-based diets aren’t defined by what they exclude. Instead, plant-based diets are characterized primarily by what they include, lots of plant foods. There’s no agreed-upon definition of a plant-based diet.

  Plant-based Vegetarian Vegan
Meat and poultry Rarely, if at all No No
Fish and seafood Rarely, if at all Pescetarians yes, others no No
Eggs and dairy Sometimes Lacto-ovo vegetarians yes No
Honey Yes Yes No
Processed and packaged foods Yes Yes Yes, if free of animal ingredients
Leather, wool, animal-tested products Not part of the diet Not part of the diet Avoided as part of the lifestyle
Plant-based has no single definition; the column shows the most common usage.

What foods can you eat on a Plant-Based diet?

As stated in the previous section, a plant-based diet differs by individuals. But in general, foods that are allowed include:

  • Grains
  • Vegetables
  • Legumes
  • Fruit
  • Oils
  • Processed foods
  • Animal products (seldom)

What Foods Do Plant-Based diets Avoid?

If you are, for example, following a pescetarian diet, you would avoid all meat and animal products except fish and crustaceans. But if you are a lacto-ovo-vegetarian, you would avoid all meat but still eat eggs and dairy products.

Bulk bins of dried beans, lentils and seeds
Photo by wei on Unsplash

Plant-Based vs Vegan Diets: What Is A Vegan Diet?

The vegan diet is more than just a diet; it is a lifestyle. The lifestyle component distinguishes it from a plant-based diet that avoids meat completely. The dietary portion does not include animal products like meat, fish, egg, dairy, and honey. 

With veganism, the lifestyle implications are what make it truly shine. For example, you will avoid leather and other materials made from animals, live sustainably, avoid products that involve animal testing, avoid brands with a known history of animal cruelty, and support companies that do not test on animals.

When embracing veganism, you may find your calling and become involved in activism for animals and their rights.

What Foods Do You Eat?

When following a vegan diet, your options are plentiful. You can eat these foods:

  • Grains
  • Vegetables
  • Legumes
  • Fruit
  • Oils
  • Processed foods

What Foods Do You Avoid on a Vegan Diet?

And as implied, you will avoid any animal product derived foods, like:

  • Meat
  • Seafood
  • Honey
  • Dairy products
People shopping for fresh produce at a market
Photo by Sofia Rodrigues on Unsplash

Potential Benefits of a Vegan Diet

When it comes to plant-based vs vegan diets, both can come with some benefits. According to the Cleveland Clinic, if you choose to follow a whole food plant-based diet, meaning a diet limiting oils, added sugars, and processed foods, you can lower your risk of developing:

  1. Colon and breast cancer
  2. Diabetes
  3. Hypertension
  4. Heart Disease

Additionally, if most of your food consists of vegetables, fruit, legumes, whole grains, nuts, and seeds, you will consume plenty of antioxidants and phytochemicals. Antioxidants reduce cell damage by protecting your cells from free radicals. And phytochemicals do a variety of functions in the body but ultimately help fight disease. 

What the Research Says

Of course, studies that follow large numbers of people over years aren’t able to establish cause and effect (other factors might explain the results). Still, results have been fairly consistent.

In the EPIC-Oxford study, which followed about 48,000 UK adults for 18 years, vegetarians and vegans had 22 percent less ischemic heart disease than meat eaters (equivalent to 10 fewer cases per 1,000 people over 10 years). They also had 20 percent more stroke (three additional cases per 1,000 people), mostly the hemorrhagic type.

WHAT THE BIG STUDIES FOUND
22%
less heart disease in vegetarians and vegans
20%
more strokes
25%
lower heart risk on a whole-food plant diet
32%
higher heart risk on a junk-food plant diet
43%
more fractures in vegans

Another large prospective cohort study, the Adventist Health Study 2, also found a statistically significant reduction in all-cause mortality among vegetarians (12 percent lower; combining all types of vegetarians) compared with nonvegetarians. The Adventist Health Study 2 included more than 73,000 Seventh-day Adventists in North America.

The largest reduction was seen among pesco-vegetarians (those who eat fish but no other types of meat), with 19 percent lower all-cause mortality; vegans had 15 percent lower all-cause mortality, although this did not reach statistical significance.

Vegetarians have lower body weight, cholesterol and LDL cholesterol and blood glucose than meat eaters.

Overall, according to a 2017 meta-analysis of 96 studies, vegetarians have an 8 percent lower rate of cancer overall and vegans have a 15 percent reduction; vegetarians have a 25 percent reduction in ischemic heart disease. No reduction was found for all cause mortality or cancer mortality. Confounders, other factors besides diet, cannot be fully accounted for in such studies.

Why ‘Plant-Based’ on a Label Is Not a Health Claim

For example, Harvard researchers followed more than 200,000 nurses and health professionals and calculated two diet quality scores: one based on eating more fruits, vegetables, nuts, legumes, whole grains and healthy oils, and the other based on eating more sweets, sweetened beverages, french fries, refined grains and fruit juice.

People with the highest healthy plant-based diet score had a 25 percent lower risk of coronary heart disease whereas people with the highest unhealthy plant-based diet score had a 32 percent higher risk of coronary heart disease.

The point being that plant-based does not equal healthy. A bowl of lentils is very different from a box of plant-based frozen nuggets.

A carton of oat milk next to a cup of coffee
Photo by Madalyn Cox on Unsplash

Plant-based is good, but not all plant-based foods are created equal. For example, ultra-processed plant foods, or UPFs (think packaged breads, sweets, snacks, sweetened beverages, some meat alternatives, etc.) are not your friends.

In a 2024 analysis of almost 127,000 adults in the UK Biobank, researchers found that for every 10 percentage points of daily energy from UPFs that were plant-based, the risk of cardiovascular disease increased by 5 percent and risk of dying from CVD increased by 12 percent.

On the flip side, for every 10 percentage points of energy from minimally-processed plant foods, risk of CVD decreased by 7 percent and risk of CVD death decreased by 13 percent.

The bottom line? Plant-based is great, but what happened to those plants on their way to your plate matters, too.

Supplement capsules spread out on a table
Photo by Supliful – Supplements On Demand on Unsplash

What Are the Nutrition Concerns for Plant-Based and Vegan Diets?

The main nutrient concerns for a plant-based diet and a vegan diet are very similar. They include concern for: vitamin B12, vitamin D, omega-3 fatty acids, calcium, iron, and zinc.

But according to the 2016 position statement by the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics (AND), a well-planned vegetarian and vegan diet can be nutritionally whole and adequate for all stages of life, including infancy to older adults and athletes. Both a vegetarian and vegan diet can help prevent and treat certain diseases. 

A well-planned diet includes regularly consuming foods fortified with the nutrients of concern like vitamin B12, D, and omega-3 fatty acids. It can also involve taking a daily supplement to ensure that you do not come short in meeting your daily vitamin and minerals needs.

Also Read: These are the 5 best medicinal mushrooms to add to your diet

Nutrient by Nutrient: Where to Get It

A 2021 systematic review summarizing 141 studies on nutrient adequacy on plant-based diets found that, compared to omnivores, people eating plant-based diets consumed less protein (but still within recommendations), as well as more fiber, folate, vitamin C, vitamin E, and magnesium.

Potential nutrients of concern included vitamin B12, vitamin D, iron, zinc, iodine, calcium, and long chain omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA), with vegans consuming the least vitamin B12, calcium, and iodine. These nutrients can be addressed through fortification and supplementation, as well as by paying attention to food choices.

NUTRIENTS TO WATCH
Where plant eaters get them
Vitamin B12
supplement, fortified cereal, plant milk, nutritional yeast
Vitamin D
sun, fortified juice and milk, UV-treated mushrooms, lichen D3
Omega-3s
algae oil, flax, chia, hemp, walnuts
Iron
lentils, beans, tofu, pumpkin seeds, fortified cereal + vitamin C
Calcium
calcium-set tofu, kale, bok choy, fortified plant milk, almonds
Zinc
beans, nuts, seeds, whole grains
Iodine
iodized salt, seaweed

Protein. Protein is probably the nutrient people worry about the most, but the above review found that plant-based dieters met recommended intakes. It’s fairly easy to get enough protein by including a variety of sources like seitan, tempeh, tofu, edamame, lentils, chickpeas, and even whole grains.

Try to spread out your protein intake through the day instead of having most of it at dinner.

Vitamin B12. There’s no reliable plant source. In a review of 18 studies, anywhere from 11 to 90 percent of vegetarians (depending on the population studied) were deficient, with vegans in worse shape than vegetarians.

Fortified cereals, plant milks and nutritional yeasts can help, but a B12 supplement (weekly or daily) is your best bet, and the advice you’ll get from pretty much anywhere.

Vitamin D. This is tricky for everyone, because the major source of vitamin D is sunshine. Fortified products (juice and milk), UV-treated mushrooms and supplementation in winter months can help. Vitamin D2 is always from plant sources; most vitamin D3 supplements are made from lanolin (sheep’s wool), but vegans can find vitamin D3 supplements made from lichen.

Omega-3 fats. Plant sources of omega-3 fatty acids include flaxseed, chia and hemp seeds, and walnuts. However, these contain the omega-3 fat ALA, which is only inefficiently converted in the body to EPA and DHA, the omega-3 fats that we associate with fish consumption.

If you’re thinking of adding an omega-3 supplement, consider algae oil, as it’s where the fish get their omega-3s from to begin with, and it will provide you directly with EPA and DHA.

Iron. Plant-based sources of iron, such as lentils, beans, tofu, pumpkin seeds and fortified cereals provide less bioavailable iron than animal sources, but vitamin C (peppers, tomatoes, citrus fruits) enhances its absorption. Avoid drinking tea or coffee with meals as they contain compounds that reduce iron absorption (drink an hour before or after meals).

Calcium and bone. Calcium-set tofu, kale, bok choy, fortified plant milks and almonds are good sources of calcium. Calcium is important for strong bones, but so is protein and maintaining a healthy body weight.

Vegans in the EPIC-Oxford study had a 43 percent higher risk of any fracture and more than twice the risk of hip fractures (an excess of 15 cases per 1,000 people over 10 years) compared with meat eaters. This increased risk was reduced, but not eliminated, after adjustment for body weight, calcium and protein intakes, so all three factors seem to play a role.

Zinc and iodine. Vegetarians should perhaps aim for more than the target amount of zinc because its absorption is reduced by the high fiber and phytate content of nuts, seeds, beans and whole grains.

Vegetarians in the US who eat dairy and use iodized salt rarely need to be concerned about their iodine intake. Those who do neither should consider using iodized salt or taking an iodine supplement. Iodine can also be obtained from seaweed.

A couple cooking vegetables together in a home kitchen
Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

Plant-Based vs Vegan Diets: Which Diet Is Right For You?

Finding out which diet is best for you depends on a few factors. 

  1. Dedication
  2. Purpose

If you are interested in a plant-based diet or a vegetarian diet, please try it out for yourself. Giving up meat or solely eating fish if you are a pescetarian may seem like an arduous task at first, but you will learn to adapt.

There are plenty of meat alternatives to try, and you can transition from a meat-eating diet slowly if need be.

Suppose you are even a bit curious or fully willing to transition to veganism and the lifestyle that comes with it. Then, more power to you! Although you will no longer consume animal products, your culinary options are not heavily limited like you may fear. 

If you are nervous about making this substantial dietary shift. In that case, I recommend going on social media websites like YouTube, TikTok, Twitter. There you can read posts or watch informational videos from Registered Dietitians like me, who speak about how to optimize your health on a vegan diet, recommended fortified food and vitamins, etc. 

Also Read: 10 Dietitian-Approved Tips to Help You Stick to a Plant-Based Diet

Then, I recommend you dive into the world of vegan recipes and cooking videos to get yourself accustomed. If you want simple meals to prepare in under 10 minutes, there’s a video for that. If you desire fancy, complex meals, there are videos for that as well. There are videos for every aspect of plant-based and vegan recipes.

Lastly, since the vegan diet does not exclude processed foods, I can almost guarantee there is a replacement for whichever non-vegan food you feel that you may miss. The food industry’s innovations with meat alternatives and vegan cheese alone are astonishing.

Plant-Based vs Vegan Diets: The Verdict

THE VERDICT
Plant-based, built on whole foods
PLANT-BASED
better pick for most people
VEGAN
fine, with a B12 supplement

So which is better? For most people, a plant-based diet built on whole foods.

Now that we’ve gone over what it means to be vegan and what the plant-based diet can encompass, are you interested in trying out either? Before committing to veganism of the plant-based diet, we always recommend doing your research. As mentioned in this article, it can be easy not to meet daily nutritional needs.

If you do not feel comfortable researching this topic on your own, please contact a health professional like a dietitian specializing in helping individuals following a vegetarian or vegan diet. You do not have to go on this journey alone. 

Going plant-based with your milk too? Note that some plant-based milks aren’t ideal for certain medical conditions.

The Greenest Wellness Score

Is your neighborhood healthy?

Get a free report on your tap water, air quality, walkability and more

Leave a comment

Have something to add? Tell us what you would change, or what has worked for you.

Every comment is read before it appears, so yours may take a day to show up.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *